Moby Duck

I just finished reading “Moby Duck”, which was recommended to me by Liz Roosevelt.  This is a fascinating and enlightening book based upon what seems to be a slim premise – to find out what happened to 28,800 bath toys which were lost at sea just south of the Aleutian Islands on January 10, 1992. The author, Donovan Hohn was a high school teacher who learned of the toy spill through an essay written by one of his students. Hohn assigned his journalism students to write an essay on the “archaeology of the ordinary.”  One student chose to write about his rubber duck which he carried for luck.  He mentioned the toys spill, and that the toys were expected to have drifted through the Bering Strait, the Northwest Passage, the Canadian Arctic and the Labrador Sea, and down to Nova Scotia, arriving sometime in 2003.

And so the odyssey begins.  This is more than just an indulgent quest to satisfy an individual’s curiosity.  Hohn is a very talented writer whose inquiries lead him from manufacturing plants in China, on to remote beaches in Alaska to search for washed up ducks, on an ice breaker in the Northwest Passage, the vast Pacific Ocean off of Hawaii on a scientific research vessel.  Along the way, readers learn about container vessels and how they are loaded, rogue waves, Irminger rings, the Great Pacific Gyre and some disastrous Arctic explorations of the 19^th and early 20^th centuries.   His inquiries are wide ranging and thoughtful.

He interviews scientists, environmentalists from across the spectrum, ship captains and crew, manufacturers and lawyers.  He examines plastics in all forms and shapes, and the catastrophic effect plastic is having on our oceans and environment.  So little is recycled, and so much winds up on our beaches (some beaches in Hawaii are composed almost entirely of plastic sand), in the ocean as microscopic particles where it is mistaken as food by sea creatures, or floating endlessly in the ocean.

This is not a grim book, full of depressing facts and gloomy predictions for the future.  It is a frequently very funny, always enlightening and completely original book.  I very highly recommend it.   

John Turner Lecture

Friends of the Bay supporters had a virtual hike around Long Island at our lecture on Wednesday, March 3.  Noted Long Island environmentalist John Turner read excerpts from his newly updated and revised edition of Exploring the Other Island.  The book is an excellent resource for anyone who wants to get to know the natural side of Long Island better, and there is no better guide than John.  Carl Safina considers John to be “the all-around most experienced, most knowledgeable and most devoted person I know with regard to scientifically appreciating , lucidly explaining and effectively helping to protect this fish shaped Island.”

John told a story about an encounter with an individual in Yellowstone , who upon learning that John came from Long Island, mad e a disparaging remark about the environment on Long Island, and that there is very little worthwhile  here in terms of the natural world (obviously that person never came to Oyster Bay).  Admittedly, there are environmental challenges here, and there has been a lot of habitat destruction and compromise.  However, if a person was to visit all the sites mentions in his book they would be rewarded with a whole new respect and understanding of Long Island’s great natural beauty. 

Exploring the Other Island is arranged by season, so an early March lecture was  perfect timing to start a virtual hike.  John first read a quote about wildflowers from a book written in 1670:  “the country itself to send forth such a fragrant smell that it may be perceived at sea before they can make the land.”   He then began with the earliest of spring harbingers – the nesting of Great Horned owls, the emergence of tiger salamanders and spring wildflowers, the return of piping plovers and spring peepers.   Our spring songbirds are already leaving their wintering grounds in South America to make their long journeys north.  There haven’t been any ospreys seen in Oyster Bay yet, but they should be back in the next couple of weeks. 

Birds are not the only animals that migrate.  The alewives (or river herrings) will be returning to their streams to breed as well.  One of the challenges they face are dams or other obstacles to their passage.  One of the actions recommended in the forthcoming Watershed Action Plan will be to  install fish ladders or remove blockages to restore historic alewife runs. 

The depth and breadth of John’s knowledge of Long Island’s environment was clear as he went through the seasons and around the Island.  I think everyone in the audience learned something that night.  For instance, I never knew that Long Island had once been one of the top five producers of cranberries in the country.  The last commercial cranberry bog , which was in Manorville, closed in 1975.  There are sites on Long Island where cranberries still grow.  We also learned that Woodcocks have the nickname of the “flying meatloaf”.  If you’ve ever seen a woodcock, it makes perfect sense. 

Max Wheaton, the Poet Laureate of Nassau County was in attendance at the lecture, and he was given a challenge of writing a poem to the milkweed.  For so many who are allergic, milkweed may not be a thing of beauty, but the pods in late summer and early fall are really stunning.  

A recurring theme throughout the night was the need for responsible stewardship and appreciation of Long Island’s land and waters.  There are many simple actions that can be taken, recycling, using less water, not using plastic bags when we go shopping that seem small, but taken together, make a difference. Supporting organizations you believe in is critical.  Quoting from Exploring the Other Island “It is difficult for many of us to effect change in the decisions taking place in corporate board rooms and governmental committees due to the time and energy it typically takes to become involved in the political process.   Here’s where conservation and environmental organizations play a surrogate, yet critical, role to your direct involvement by reflecting and expressing your concern for the environment to corporate and political America.  They are able to marshal and focus your support for protecting the environment to achieve gains in protecting wildlife, preserving open space, promoting renewable energy, and in a whole host of other important conservation areas.”  With the current budget crisis playing out in Washington, local organizations are going to be taking on more of the work to protect and preserve our environment. 

John autographed copies of his book and we do have a very few left.  All the proceeds will benefit Friends of the Bay, so if you would like a copy, please let me know.  

Congressional Funding

As I am writing this article, congress is debating a Continuing Resolution to extend government funding for the rest of the year.  By the time you are reading this article, voting may have taken place.  My column last week spoke of the use of Facebook in discovering interesting articles.   This week, Facebook and other social media applications were key tools in helping to spread awareness of the need to make phone calls to help protect our environment.   The astonishing spread of calls for freedom and less restrictive government in the Mideast is also testament to the efficacy of these tools.  All the coverage I have seen gives credit to usage of Facebook,twitter , and email  in arranging and coordinating the protests, and in allowing unedited coverage of these events to spread worldwide. 

The Long Island Sound Study is composed of groups from along the southern side of Connecticut and the north shore of Long Island who work together to protect the water quality of the Long Island Sound.  There is a broad diversity of representation.  Some of them members are locally based like Friends of the Bay or the Hempstead Harbor Protection Committee, there are municipal members like the Town of Oyster Bay, representatives from fishing associations, larger regional organizations like Citizens Campaign for the Environment, Audubon New York and Connecticut, and governmental agencies including the Environmental Protection Agency and the Dcpartment of Environmental Conservation.  All of us work together to protect the Long Island Sound and its watershed areas.

Some of the larger organizations have staff members who closely follow what is occurring in Washington and report back to their constituents and to members of the Long Island Sound Study.  This week the amount of urgent emails from environmental organizations was more than I have ever seen.  An email Friends of the Bay sent began with “The environment is under assault in Congress right now”.  These are difficult economic times, and tough choices have to be made.  It seems though that cuts are not being made evenly, or with regard to damage that may be done that is irreversible.  Once a habitat is destroyed, it is gone forever.  As someone  famously said “land – they aren’t making any more of it.”

One of the tables of funding appropriations that was circulated was astonishing to me: 

SF Bay	$7m	$4.847m
Puget Sound	$50m	$50m
South Florida	$2.168m	$2.061m
Mississippi River Basin	$0	$6m
Long Island Sound	$7m	$2.962m
Gulf of Mexico	$6m	$4.464m
Lake Champlain	$4m	$1.399m

As you see, funding for the Long Island Sound was being cut by more than 50%, to 2.962 million.  The most the sound ever received was $7 million.  Our shellfishing industry alone contributes $7 million to our regional economy.  $7 million was the most the Sound ever received. 

Understandably, groups were very concerned about these deep cuts.  It had been anticipated that funding would remain at the 2010 level, at $7 million.  Emails were sent out by Audubon New York and Connecticut, requesting assistance in reaching out to legislators.  Friends o f the Bay and Citizens Campaign for the Environment sent out eblasts to our membership and posted alerts on our Facebook pages, which were in turn shared by the Hempstead Harbor Protection Committee and Boating Times Long Island.  I heard from representative’s assistants that they were receiving phone calls as a result of these cooperative efforts.  In these very difficult times, when government agencies and non profit organizations are stretched to the maximum, cooperation and support is key to achieving goals.  Public support is crucial.  Your legislators need to know what is important to their constituents. 

As part of this cooperative between organizations, Sean Mahar of Audubon New York provided the following  talking points to use when calling legislators regarding this Continuing Resolution – these can also be used as the basis of a letter or an email to your representative.   The Continuing Resolution may have already been decided as you read this column.  It is still very important to let your legislators know that the environment (and the jobs produced or protected, tourism income, etc) is important to you. 

“Across the nation, our important water ecosystems like the Great Lakes and Long Island Sound are under constant threat from pollution and habitat loss.  We face a massive backlog of projects to clean up and restore these important engines of the regional and national economy. 

The cuts proposed in this Continuing Resolution disproportionately target these important water and wildlife programs, that invest in programs that put people to work restoring the waters that millions of people depend on each day. 

For example, in my district, Long Island Sound is a national economic and ecological treasure that contributes more than $8 billion per year to the regional economy from commercial and recreational fishing, ecotourism and other water dependent businesses. More than 28 million people, or nearly 10 percent of the population of the United States, live within 50 miles of Long Island Sound, and the resultant development has led to increasingly poor ecosystem health.

For the Sound, federal funding through the Long Island Sound Restoration and Stewardship Acts is desperately needed to reach the goals of the Comprehensive Conservation and Management Plan (CCMP) that has been developed by the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Long Island Sound Study (LISS).  Yet this CR cuts this program by over 50%!

This attack by the House Republicans on environmental spending is the wrong course, and does little to put our nation on the road to economic and environmental recovery.  Investments in local environmental restoration jobs that cannot be exported elsewhere must be prioritized and not undone when the demand for this funding could not be greater. 

In New York alone, over $70 million worth of projects was applied for in the first year of funding through the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, and while the $20 million in funding received by the state is just beginning to yield dividends, we cannot afford to lose ground. 

The longer we wait to reverse the decline of our coastal ecosystems like the Great Lakes, Long Island Sound, New York Harbor, and other of our nation’s great water ecosystems, the costs to bring these places back increase drastically, greatly decreasing the returns on our nation’s investment. 

Therefore I urge you to vote against these cuts to the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, Long Island Restoration and Stewardship Acts and other EPA Water Programs are the wrong course, and amendments that would handicap the EPA to protect the water and air resources we all depend on. 

In addition, I urge you to oppose the elimination of funding for the State Wildlife Grants Program, the nation’s core program for keeping species from becoming endangered and keeps people working to monitor and improve the habitats that our fish and wildlife rely on. 

This proposed elimination comes at a time when bird and wildlife watching is the fastest growing outdoor recreation bringing in billions in revenue from this ecotourism.  Our state wildlife agencies and organizations need this which every state and territory  in the nation gets their share of the funding based on a formula.  Therefore every state benefits and every state will be negatively impacted by this program’s elimination.

This is why I urge my colleagues to vote against this assault on environmental programs, and take a scalpel to our systemic budgetary problems, instead of a hatchet to funding for our forest, water and wildlife.  The health of our economy, future generations and the planet depend on it.”

Oysters to the Rescue in New York

Facebook is something people either seem to love or hate.  Very few people are neutral  about it.  It can be a huge distraction, but used properly, it can be a very informative and engaging tool.  Besides connecting with family and friends, more and more organizations and businesses are using facebook to reach out and spread messages.  Its less technologically challenging than an RSS feed, and easy to set up and subscribe to.  And yes, Friends of the Bay has a facebook page, so if you are on Facebook, become a fan! 

One of the articles which was posted on my facebook page concerned a lecture given at the Museum of Modern Art.  The museum held an exhibit called Rising Currents, which featured plans for dealing with the impacts of coastal sea level rise on New York City.  As part of this exhibit, a lecture was given by Kate Orff.  Kate is a landscape architect and Assistant Professor at Columbia University, and is a founder of a firm called SCAPE.  Kate’s work at Columbia focuses on the integration of design disciplines and earth sciences. 

Kate explained in her lecture that she is passionate about the how the geography of America has shaped history and the American character.  She is attempting to blend the fields of urbanism and ecology to address sea level rise and climate change.  In her efforts to do so she has found a “new hero in the global climate change war, and that is the eastern oyster…albeit a very small creature and very modest, this creature is incredible, because it can agglomerate into these mega-reef structures, it can grow, you can grow it, and did I mention its quite tasty.”  (well, we knew that!).  Kate used the oyster as a basis for a design project she calls oyster-tecture. 

The crux of this very interesting idea is to utilize the power of oysters, eel grass and mussels to help combat sea level rise and cleanse even the infamous Gowanus Canal of pollution.  At one time, oysters the size of dinner plates grew in the canal, so this is kind of a back to the future idea.  Kate believes that by developing an oyster reef in the harbor, the islands that were in New Harbor at one time would be re-created and would help to serve as wave buffers.  The oysters, of course, would provide water filtration and cleansing.  Kate certainly gives a lot of credit to the role of oysters in New York’s history – stating that New York was built on the backs of oystermen, and the streets built on oyster shells. 

She goes on to describe how artificial reefs might be built using ropes, and how possibly the reefs could even become a public space.  Flupsys (floating upwelling systems) are a key part of her plans.   These are the same flupsys that can be seen at The WaterFront Center, or lining the side of Mill Neck Creek by Frank M. Flower and Sons hatchery in Bayville.  Oyster gardens are also part of her plans for the canal. 

It’s a very interesting concept, and one that should be explored further.  The full lecture can be seen from a link at the Friends of the Bay blog.   

Long Island Sound Health

The 2010 Edition of Long Island Sound Health is out - it is a wealth of information for anyone interested in Long Island Sound.  Its especially valuable for students! Long Island Sound Health

Oyster Bay/Cold Spring Harbor Protection Committee Coordinator Position

Coordinator

Oyster Bay / Cold Spring Harbor Protection Committee

Oyster Bay, New York

Introduction

The Oyster Bay/ Cold Spring Harbor watershed located on the north shore of Long Island, New York is a 40 square mile watershed that has been subject to increasing environmental threatsin recent years. These include illegal dumping, polluted stormwater, development pressureand impairments to shellfishing, public bathing, fish consumption, habitat/hydrology, aquatic life and recreation.

In order to help protect andenhance the water quality of these two harbors and their tributaries in the most cost-efficient and effective manner, awatershed-wide inter-municipal committee was recently formed.  Sixteen (16) of the  eighteen (18) municipalities located within the watershed have so far agreed to join the committee, which is  known as the Oyster Bay / Cold Spring Harbor Protection Committee (OB/CSH PC).

The Town of Oyster Bay (one of those municipalities) has secured a grant under the Long Island Sound Futures Fund which provides funding to hire a part time Coordinator to facilitate the further development of the Committee.

Responsibilities

Duties include but are not limited to the following:

o   Advance the current steering committee to a working committee

o   Develop a mission statement, a needs statement, and a work plan

o   Investigate various options for OB/CSH PC’s legal structure, decision-making, future funding mechanisms and procedures for those municipalities who want to join the partnership, develop grant proposals as appropriate.

o   .  Investigate Inter-Municipal Agreement (“IMA”) structures and develop an IMA for the municipalities to sign and join the partnership

o   Conduct educational outreach and coordinate among the municipalities

o   Develop a website

o   Coordinate with the Friends of the Bay in the development of a Watershed Action Plan. The Plan will lead to future actions that improve water quality, protect habitat and living resources, educate and involve the public, improve the long term understanding of how to manage the Long Island Sound and its embayments, monitor progress and redirect management efforts.

o   In addition to the Watershed Action Plan, compile all existing plans related to the harbor complex.

o   Investigate the establishment of model codes for the participating municipalities.

o   Develop grant proposals as appropriate.

To the extent that time is available within the established hours, additional duties may be determined by OB/CSH PC.

The position may require attendance at evening meetings.

Office space for the Coordinator will be available at the Friends of the Bay offices located in the hamlet of Oyster Bay.

In addition to the amount described above, the Coordinator will have a budget for contractual services, supplies and materials and travel to carry out the duties described above.

Qualifications

The criteria to be used by the Town in evaluating these proposals shall be the following:

     -      The magnitude, scope and complexity of the services to be rendered

           

     -      The experience of the Proposer in assignments of similar size, scope and complexity

     -      Special knowledge relevant to the project

     -       The Proposer's knowledge and experience with municipal governments; with Oyster Bay and Cold Spring Harbors; with federal, state and local laws and regulations aimed at protecting watersheds and water quality and with various stakeholder and interest groups that are likely to be involved with the mission of OB/CSH PC.

-          The Proposer’s writing and public speaking abilities.

-            The Proposer’s past performance with the Town and/or any of the other Committee municipalities or other municipalities facing similar needs.

-            Time constraints and deliverability service;

-            The ability of the Proposer to work by himself or herself; and

-            Experience using Microsoft Office (including Word and Excel), internet. GIS a plus. 

Compensation

The value of the Coordinator’s contract shall not exceed $41,615 over a period of 15 months.  The Coordinator will be paid on an hourly basis. It is anticipated that the Coordinator will work an average of 20 to 25 hours per week.  The Coordinator shall work as an independent contractor for the Town of Oyster Bay and shall be paid upon submission and approval of a Town claim form, time sheets and any other backup determined necessary by the Town.  Benefits are not included with this position.  The position will be subject to quarterly reviews.

Closing Date

The closing date and time are Friday, January 28^th at 4:00 pm.  Proposals must be RECEIVED by that time. Proposals must be submitted in hard copy and mailed or hand-delivered.  No electronic proposals will be considered.

Additional Details

Additional details can be found in the Request For Proposals (RFP) package that will be provided upon request.

To Apply

Contact Eric Swenson at (516) 677-5790 or eswenson@oysterbay-ny.gov to request a Request For Proposals (RFP) package.

Bottled Water Report from the Environmental Working Group

The Environmental Working Group has just published its survey of 173 bottled water products.  No surprise - tap water is best!  Read the full results and compare your brand here - Environmental Working Group Bottled Water Survey

2010 Stormwater Report

The Town of Oyster Bay has published their draft stormwater report, it is available on the Town of Oyster Bay website.

OB/CSH Protection Committee featured in Talk of the Town!

Update on Centre Island Property

On December 27, the Centre Island Zoning Board of Appeals denied the applicants request for several variances that would have allowed for the building of a house on an environmentally sensitive Centre Island Beach.

According to state law, three members of the five-member board have to vote in favor of the variances in order to approve them.  Because one recused himself and another has moved from Centre Island, only three members voted.  Two voted in favor of the variances.  One brave member voted against them to prevent this potentially harmful development. 

The ZBA member that acted to protect the beach said there were several factors in her decision.  She noted that the entire parcel of land is below the 12-foot elevation required by the Village of Centre Island’s building code.  She also pointed out that the proposed septic system would be built on a beach situated between Oyster Bay and a tidal wetland that is regularly flooded. 

This same ZBA member, who has lived on Centre Island for 33 years and served on the board for many years, also pointed to what appear to be inconsistencies between the plot plans that the applicant presented to New York’s Department of Conservation in his application for a wetland permit and those he sent to the Village. 

The Village Attorney noted that the applicants lot did not meet the legal requirements for Centre Island lots when it was created in the 1950s.  The Village Attorney also said he could not find any evidence that a variance was granted at that time.

It is not clear what will happen next.  The applicant has engaged a law firm that prides itself on its ability to use the court system to overcome local opposition to developing controversial projects. During the hearings that came before this week’s decision, the applicant's lawyer made it clear that they were prepared to litigate if the Village did not provide the requested variances.
 This is good news for the moment.  We will keep you apprised of changes if they occur.
 Thank you for your support. 

Christmas Greetings

All of us at Friends of the Bay wish you the best of health and happiness in 2011.  We are looking forward to an exciting and productive year, with new opportunities to protect and preserve our beautiful harbor and upland areas.  Our Watershed Action Plan will be completed in 2011. It will provide a roadmap for on the ground initiatives that will address many of the issues identified in the State of the Watershed Report.  This is a vision for the future that is being developed by the community.

Some of the programs and initiatives we are looking forward to working on include a restoration of Beekman Creek, developing an Information Resource Center, planning a Blueway Trail, fish passage projects and creation of bio-retention basins.  In addition, we will continue to monitor the water in our harbor, ponds and streams, perform beach cleanups and conduct our lecture series.

These projects will all be accomplished in partnership with local municipalities, other organizations and with support from volunteers and residents.  Friends of the Bay believes that when citizens and communities are informed and engaged in local decision making a powerful vision for the future can be developed and environmental issues can be resolved. 

Working on the Watershed Action Plan has been both a humbling and energizing experience.  I am very grateful to all of you who have come to the planning meetings, submitted comments and offered expertise and energy to this project.  You have shown yourselves to be deeply committed to your community and to protecting this beautiful part of the world. 

Concerned Citizens of Centre Island

The Concerned Citizens of Centre Island have asked us to help spread the news regarding the development of an extraordinary and environmentally sensitive property on Centre Island.  A decision on the proposed development is forthcoming from the Centre Island Zoning Board of Appeals. 

The property, located at 223 Beach Road, is a narrow piece of low-lying sandy beach at the base of Eastover Road.  It lies between one of the largest tidal wetlands on Long Island’s North Shore and Oyster Bay itself.  Despite the denial of a building permit, the owner now seeks substantial variances from the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) in order to develop this sensitive site.  The sewage system to this property would be built less than two feet underground and would be below the ten year flood elevation.  It poses a strong risk of sewage spills directly into Oyster Bay and the nearby wetland.    The Village of Centre Island’s own engineer has expressed his reluctance to allow the waiver of state and county sewage requirements.  Coastal sea rise also has to be considered, since this construction will be so close to the shoreline.  

As environmental caretakers and stewards, Friends of the Bay is deeply concerned regarding this property.   For over 20 years, Friends of the Bay has zealously protected the Oyster Bay/Cold Spring Harbor estuary.   The estuary is the cleanest of all the 13 embayments on the north shore of Long Island.  Residents and visitors can safely swim, fish and boat in these waters.  The possibility of having sewage discharges into the harbor is one which we take very seriously.    Our waters are home to an economically significant and environmentally sustainable shellfishing industry, as well as being a recreational resource for swimmers and fishermen.  The Oyster Bay National Wildlife Refuge is a home for thousands of migratory waterfowl, and has been designated an Important Bird Area by the National Audubon Society. 

The Town of Oyster Bay and Nassau County are making a substantial investment in connecting an inadequate sewage treatment facility in Locust Valley (the Birches) to the sewage treatment facility in Glen Cove in order to remediate sewage discharages.  To allow another sewage overflow situation to possibly develop does not seem to be a wise course for the Village of Centre Island.  Friends of the Bay is not anti-development, provided that projects address environmental concerns.  Some proposals, such as the one at 223 Beach Road, are so environmentally sensitive that these concerns cannot be alleviated.  This property should be considered for acquisition and preservation.

The Concerned Citizens for Centre Island have created an online petition which can be found at www.karma411.com/concernedcitizens.   The petition, as well as more information regarding the site, can be found there. 

Mill Pond Overlook

Members of the Oyster Bay community came together in the Friends of the Bay office on the evening of November 18 to review conceptual plans prepared by Cameron Engineering for the Mill Pond Overlook property.   The plans were developed in consultation with an advisory committee which consisted of representatives from the Town Of Oyster Bay, United States Fish and Wildlife Service, the North Shore Land Alliance and Friends of the Bay.    

Cameron Engineering considered the topography and ecology of the site in developing their plans.  There are some magnificent beech, tulip and black walnut trees, as well as some remnant ornamental species.   Invasive species, like Norway Maples, Asian bittersweet, and English Ivy would need to be removed.  Many bird species utilize the woods, especially during the spring and fall migrations. 

There are interesting man-made features on the property.  One of them, an old concrete pad on the lower part of the wetland may have been a cow barn at one time.  I remember seeing a picture of cows grazing on the property in the early 1900s.  If anyone has knowledge of this, or has any information on this concrete pad, your assistance would be appreciated in clarifying what purpose this served.  There is also an old chimney which has toppled over. 

There are challenges and opportunities in developing a conceptual plan.  There are steep slopes between the upper meadow and the lower edge of the property bordering the Mill Pond, as well as erosion and illegal dumping activity.  There are multiple opportunities for educational activities, and passive recreation. 

There were two conceptual plans presented by Cameron Engineering.   Both plans call for signage and educational materials which will be used to highlight ecological and historical features.  The signage would be vandal resistant, and possibly podcasts or audio walking tours could be developed to further inform visitors to the site.  A split rail fence along the lower property edge was proposed to form a boundary with the Refuge property and protect habitat, as well as a fence along the slope at the hill top for safety.  Some trees (Norway Maples) would be removed and others limbed up to allow open views to the pond and encourage understory growth.  Sufficient tree cover would be retained to prevent erosion.  The major differences in the plans are the way in which parking is designed, and the manner in which the upper meadow area is utilized.  The complete presentation, including the draft conceptual plans, can be viewed on the Friends of the Bay website at www.friendsofthebay.org.

After the presentation, attendees divided into three groups to consider the conceptual plans, comment upon them and make suggestions.  The general consensus of the group present seemed to be that the best use of the space would be for passive recreational activities and education and that “less is more.”  If you wish to submit a comment, or make a suggestion about the way in which the Mill Pond Overlook could be utilized, you may do so at Friends of the Bay’s blog, which can be reached from our website. 

Barry Lamb, President of the Board of Friends of the Bay said “It was evident that the conceptual plans presented were already very in tune with what the community had in mind for this property; low impact access that allows for the enjoyment of this beautiful area. The community members who attended offered some very insightful ideas, many of which will likely be incorporated into the final plan.”

The next step in the process is to incorporate the public comments into the draft final plan.  Comments on the Mill Pond Overlook Plan can be submitted until December 10. 

Draft Watershed Action Plan

A draft Watershed Action Plan document has been circulated to the Steering Committee. This document is not a draft of  the actual Watershed Action Plan but an outline of the plan goals, objectives, and action items as a starting point for discussion with the steering committee. 

We expect this draft to evolve based on feedback from the steering committee. Once the group reaches consensus on the goals, objectives and action items, we will begin to write the actual plan, which will be formatted similar to the Nissequogue River Stewardship Acton Plan and will also contain other items to meet the EPA nine elements - priorities, responsibilities, schedule, outcomes, load reductions, etc. We will also be developing site specific and targeted restoration concepts as the plan develops.

You may post comments on this blog, or submit them directly to me at p.aitken@friendsofthebay.org

Mill Pond Management Plan

Thank you to all who attended the mill pond overlook meeting. The comments submitted were thoughtful and well considered. For those of who were not able to be there, we have posted a copy of the presentation which was given by Cameron engineering. You may download a copy of the powerpoint presentation here - Mill Pond Overlook.  Please submit comments, we welcome your input. 

How's The Water - The Wave by Susan Casey

I seem to finally have some time to catch up on some reading.  Maybe it is that I am no longer lured outside by light, and now that the night comes early, I am more inclined to stay inside and read some of the books that have caught my attention and put on my “read later” list.

One of these books is The Wave  - in Pursuit of Rogues, Freaks and Giants of the Ocean by Susan Casey.  This is a examination of the huge “rogue waves” that were once regarded as mariner’s tales.  Casey starts the book with describing a harrowing voyage taken by a British research ship in the North Sea.  The scientists aboard and their equipment were battered and damaged, but the equipment kept working and recorded seas at 60 feet, and some waves of 90 feet or more.  Waves of 87 feet or more were also recorded by instruments on an oil platform in the North Sea.

The two disparate groups interviewed by Casey about the phenomenon of rogue waves each bring their own insight and impressive knowledge of the sea.  Who would know and watch the sea better than competitive surfers?  They may not have scientific degrees (although at least one surfer pursued his love and wish to understand the sea better to acquire a doctorate in physics) but surfers have an ability to read the wind and the waves, and draw on their experience to judge the big waves.  They too increasingly avail themselves of satellite tracking and technology to monitor the weather and ocean currents, to know where the next big waves will be.  As if surfing were not inherently dangerous enough, the most highly competitive surfers now use jet skis to have themselves towed out to the highest and most dangerous waves, some 80 feet or more.  They all speak of the thrill and rush of successfully surfing such a wave, but when they falter the consequences are catastrophic and can be deadly.  Laird Hamilton, a champion surfer followed by Casey in her research, has had over 1,000 stitches and multiple broken bones. 

The physicists and oceanographers all seek to understand how rogue waves work.  Interestingly, there is no universally accepted description for what even a simple wave, such as we see lapping the shores in Oyster Bay harbor, is.  There are many complex forces at work, the interplay of wind, gravity, climate and physics, which make waves hard to understand, mode and define.  It is important to better understand waves, since every week at least two ships are lost at sea worldwide and never heard from again.  Rogue waves are believed to be the cause.  Casey makes an interesting visit to Lloyd’s of London, which insures so many international vessels, and describes the mournful ceremony of striking the Lutine bell every time a ship is lost.  The cost in human life is substantial, as is damage to the environment from the cargoes spilled into the ocean. 

The climatologists, oceanographers and physicists all agree that we know and understand the surface of the moon better than we know our oceans and sea floor.  They predict that with climate change there will be more rogue waves as the ocean warms, and storms become stronger and more frequent.  If a wave hits a populated area, as evidenced by the Indonesian Tsunami, the damage will be catastrophic. 

This is a very interesting and challenging book and would make a great addition to your winter reading list. 

the Public is Invited....

PUBLIC MEETING

MILL POND OVERLOOK

Habitat Management Plan

Thursday, November 18, 7-9 PM

At the offices of Friends of the Bay

111 South Street, Suite 2

Townsend Square

Oyster Bay

Join your neighbors and friends to provide input regarding the Habitat Management Plan for the Mill Pond Overlook property on Mill River Road.

The meeting will include a presentation by the Town of Oyster Bay’s

environmental planning consultants,

followed by the opportunity to provide suggestions and feedback

regarding the preliminary concepts shown in the presentation.

Book Review - Four Fish by Paul Greenberg

Four Fish – The Future of the Last Wild Food by Paul Greenberg is a beautifully written examination of the complexities involved in our relationship with fish as a food source.  The four fish referred to in the title are salmon, cod, tuna and sea bass.  Greenberg raises many questions – the depletion of fish stocks by overfishing to the point where the survival of species is questionable, and the practices of fish farming, which can spread disease to wild fish.  The amount of wild fish necessary to feed the fish being farmed is considerable, and depletes another stock.   He examines each of these four fish species, and the possibilities of whether or not they can be farmed. 

One of the greatest challenges posed is the very nature of the fish themselves – they roam the world’s oceans across international boundaries.  In order to protect fish stocks, nations must agree on when and where, and what methods should be used to harvest fish, if they should be harvested at all.  Greenberg makes a convincing case that it may be already too late to save bluefin tuna.  The author writes lyrically “If salmon led us out of the Neolithic caves in the highlands down to the mouths of rivers, if sea bass and other coastal perciforms led us from the safety of the shore to the reefs and rocks that surround the coasts, and if cod and the gadiforms led us beyond the sight of land to the edges of the continental shelves, tuna have taken us over the precipice of the continental shelves into the abyss of the open sea – the final frontier of fishing and the place where the wildest things are making the last argument for the importance of an untamed ocean.” 

He questions whether fish are wildlife that are sensitive to our actions and merit our sound protection and propagation in the way we take care of our terrestrially farmed animals.  For too long seafood was thought of as a crop that grows back every year and never required planting. The ocean seemed to be a limitless resource, but relentless and unsustainable industrial fish harvesting and habitat loss has taken its toll.  For example, as many as 100 million Atlantic salmon larvae hatched in the Connecticut River.  Dams and overfishing have destroyed that fishery, and there is no longer any wild Atlantic salmon

At the end of the book, Greenberg suggests four actions which need to be taken to restore the health of fisheries: 

1. a profound reduction in fishing effort.  The United Nations estimates the fishing fleet is twice as large as the oceans can support.  Fishing  fleets are subsidized by governments and consequently, wild fish are unreasonably cheap. 

2.  there should be a conversion ofsignificant portions of ocean ecosystems to no-catch areas.  Key fish breeding and nursery habitats must be preserved as safe havens if fish stocks are to rebuild harvestable numbers.  Currently, only one percent of ocean habita t is protected

3.  gloobal protection of unmanageable species – species or stocks that straddle too many nations, like Atlantic bluefin tuna is necessary

4.  protection of the bottom of the food chain.  Small forage fish like anchovies, sardines, capelin and herring, are a huge portion of fish caught. Removing the basic food source of the ocean can cause a fisheries collapse from below.

This is a marvelously written book which  raises many thoughtful and important questions.  It will be up to  us to determine how important it is to preserve the last truly wild food. 

Baywatch stayed at the dock not last week, not due to wind or weather conditions, but due to an engine malfunction.  Not the boat’s – I was in Syracuse for my niece’s wedding and my car broke down on the way to her reception.  So, I had the car towed, and spent a little time longer in Syracuse than I had planned.  Oh well, my niece and her new husband are a wonderful couple, and it was a lovely wedding, and family is what it is all about.  I’m looking forward to the next wedding already.  Our Friends of the Bay volunteers are the best, and we will be extending our season by one week to get in another round of water quality monitoring to end out our year. 

The Majestic Plastic Bag

this is an eye opening mockumentary about the migration of a plastic bag - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLgh9h2ePYw

Watershed Action Plan Meeting

The next meeting for the Watershed Action Plan will be held on Wednesday, December 1, in the library of Oyster Bay High School at 7:00 pm.  Please join us there. 

The powerpoint presentation which was given at the meeting on October 12, and the survey, can be accessed through the Friends of the Bay website.  (http://www.friendsofthebay.org/)  Please take the opportunity to view the presentation.  We have received well thought out and informed responses to our survey.  This is your opportunity to voice your concerns about the watershed.  If you have not already done so, take a minute to fill it out.